It’s time to play Review or Press Release?, in which you, the reader, must determine whether a piece of writing about a book is written by a critic or a publicist.
First up is this review in The Independent, of Shaena Lambert’s first novel, Radiance.
Ready? Go!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
A very subtle and funny writer - one I've become obsessed with over the past year - in a decidedly Muriel Spark mood. Imagine The Pr...
-
August over at Vestige.org has posted a long and very complimentary review/essay about my novel that morphs into a defense of the boring ol...
-
Mark Steyn is a dangerous idiot with a suspiciously homophobic streak for a bearded, show tunes-loving man who is drawn to big, strong, auth...
-
Terry Gilliam’s Tideland is getting some fairly harsh reviews so far, blasting it as a series of self-conciously “weird” visual images anch...
3 comments:
If my publicist wrote a press release that dull, I'd fire him/her/it.
I choose (c): high school book report. ack.
Absolute press release -- it's even worse here in Canada, where most 'authors' moonlight as 'reviewers' and praise their fellow alumni from MFA programmes
Post a Comment